Eat Our Brains

over 5 billion neurons served

Recent Brains

Other Brains

Our Brains

Old Brains

July 2007
S M T W T F S
« Jun   Aug »
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
293031  

Meta Brains

Spam Blocked


Creative Commons License
Unless otherwise stated, the material on this website is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 2.5 License.
sample

A public conversation about our worlds.

  • Monday: Morgan J. Locke
  • Tuesday: Madeleine E. Robins
  • Wednesday: Maureen F. McHugh
  • Thursday: Bradley Denton
  • Friday: Steven Gould
  • Saturday: Caroline Spector
  • Sunday: Rory Harper

Brain Activity



Thank you, J.K. Rowling

July 18th, 2007 by Maureen McHugh

Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows

When I was a kid in elementary school, I used to get in trouble for reading. It seems absurd. But when I was ten, I could read with utter concentration. I could remain immersed in Bullfinch’s Mythology when the television was on and not know that Samantha was twinkling her nose at people. If Alex and the Black Stallion had been separated and Alex had lost his memory, I never knew my mother was calling for me. After I raced through whatever work we were doing in class and opened At the Back of the North Wind, I was oblivious to the teacher calling our attention and starting the next lesson. So Mr. Fish, my fourth grade teacher, used to take my library book from me and put it on the chalk rail of the blackboard, close to the door. I could pick it up at the end of the day. Once my book had been confiscated, I was forced to fall back on drawing horses, which probably says way too much about what kind of girl I was.

I don’t read with the same fervor anymore. When I was a kid I didn’t care if it was fine literature or trash, just as long as the words marched orderly along the page. I didn’t know what a rotten social agenda lay behind At the Back of the North Wind. Now I don’t like some things and love others and I notice the dog scratching at the back door, no matter how good the book is. But I still hide in books–at the doctor’s office, in airports, even sometimes in bank lines.

I reading for a couple of months after September 11. If a story evoked real, strong feeling in me, I felt an emotional exhaustion, a kind of hangover. So I avoided the things I was reading and more and more I look at books that I was planning to read, like Zadie Smith’s White Teeth, which begins with an unsuccessful suicide, and I just didn’t want to go there. I was afraid it would make me feel complicated things.

I’m ill-equipped for the world on its own terms. I mean, if I’m not reading, I have to do things. Like clean my house and balance my checkbook. I watched a lot of television after September 11, most of it really pointless stuff on cable like the show where two couples each have 48 hours and $1,000 to redecorate a room in their friend’s house with the advice of a decorator. Fireplaces got painted purple and people wound up with lots of leopard print throw pillows. (My family called it Decorating for Sadists.) But television isn’t as convenient as a book and somehow, with commercials, it isn’t as all-encompassing, as comforting.

Then I thought of the perfect thing to read so I went to the library and checked out what was then all four of the Harry Potter books. I’m not a big reader of children’s literature. The emotional strokes are broad, the colors are bright. But right then there was something comforting about Harry Potter and The Prisoner of Azbakan. For six days I read them during my office hours at school, before I went to bed at night and during lunch. Remember the Flintstones, where technology was replaced by weird, stone age style contraptions? Where a tiny little bird had it’s beak stuck on a stone record to play music? Harry Potter is full of the magical equivalents of that: tents for camping that look small and normal on the outside but are as big as bungalows and fully furnished on the inside, or mail delivered by owls or mirrors that show your heart’s desire. It’s a vivid escape from reality, a place where I knew Harry was going to be all right–there were three more books coming in the series, so he had to be all right.

I remember a professor saying that during the Blitz in London, people read Anthony Trollope’s novels. I don’t know if it’s true or if it is some sort of English Department Urban Myth, but somehow I can see how Trollope’s six volumes of Barsetshire novels–stories about family and the everyday moral victories and failures of life–could provide a sense of continuity in a world seemingly gone mad. In fact, I plan to take a look at them myself now that Harry Potter is going to come to an end.

I don’t think that Harry dies in the end of the seventh book. I’ll find out in the 21st, even though I won’t be at a bookstore at midnight because I’m sure it will be all over the net, even if I try to avoid it. But I think that J.K. Rowling is a pretty good writer. I think the books are pretty good books. I love them, and I’m grateful for them, and a little sad (although I think it’s utterly the right thing to do) that they are almost done.

At least I like the movies, too. And there will be a couple more years of those.

Posted in Daily Life, Fantasy, Fiction, Pop. Culture | 14 Comments »

14 Responses

  1. Madeleine Robins Says:

    Me too!

    I remember crying at the end of The Last Battle, not because the world had ended, but because there were no more Narnia books to read for the first time. I expect to feel a little bit of that when I read HP7 (which I won’t get to see until Sarcasm Girl has finished it–YG is getting her copy shipped to camp, and I refuse to buy three copies just so I can read it at once). Harry Potter is not a vastly inventive series, but Rowling has woven together many many things in a new and enormously pleasing way, and I’ll miss it when the story is finally over.

  2. Caroline Spector Says:

    As much as I like Harry Potter — and I like it very much indeed — I think Phillip Pullman’s His Dark Materials trilogy is much more powerful. Pullman is hunting bigger game than Rowling.

    That said, what I love about Rowling is that she takes the society of children seriously. Or maybe it’s the whole British boarding school tradition that’s also so engaging for me as an American reader. (Tom Brown School Days, anyone?)

    The Dude pre-ordered my copy months ago. Unfortunately, I’m going to be in Tulsa at Conestoga so, though I’ll be Internet free, I suspect the ending will be out of the bag before I leave for home. Dammit.

  3. Morgan J. Locke Says:

    I’m a sucker for Harry Potter. I’m going to read the seventh as soon as it comes out, then re-read them all in a row.

  4. Rachael Says:

    Yeah, I just re-read the most recent two… and Papa and I are going to pick up Deathly Hallows at midnight.

    I, also, had a crappy teacher who would take my book and put it on the chalk board railing just about every day in seventh grade. What a jerk.

  5. Connie H. Says:

    Heh. In 3rd grade I gave up on doing the math assignments (they were boring) on the theory that the teacher wouldn’t notice with so much to grade, and spent the in-class time reading whatever I could find in the handy little library. As I remember, I was acing each math test, so without anything ever being said, I continued to do this for the rest of the year….

  6. Bradley Denton Says:

    I recall that in 5th grade, I wasn’t allowed to read just anything I wanted when my work was done . . . but I WAS allowed to read the classroom’s set of World Book encyclopedias as much as I liked.

    I came pretty close to getting through the whole set.

  7. Maureen McQ Says:

    Brad, I bet you know LOTS of fascinating if not very useful things…although useful is a relative term, isn’t it.

  8. austin kleon Says:

    I read the first 2 books, got sick of the third one after 90 pages of “Harry remembered his second year at Hogwarts when the blah blah blahblah”

    THEN, I finally gave up my Harry Potter snobbery and read #6 and loved it. Can’t wait to read #7.

  9. AUSTINKLEON.COM » Blog Archive » AND NOW I WILL PUBLICLY DECLARE MY LOVE FOR HARRY POTTER Says:

    [...] other great posts on Harry and the gang, check out Maureen’s thoughts about it being a post 9-11 fairy tale, and Eddie Campbell’s thoughts and [...]

  10. Steven Gould Says:

    Two copies of the book arrive on Saturday–one for Noble Girl, one for Twilight Ninja.

    I’m interested for sure but I’m also excited about this:

    http://www.apple.com/trailers/newline/thegoldencompass/

  11. Paula Helm Murray Says:

    My fifth grade teacher cut a deal with me. If I finished my work I could read in class. Until she retired, she mentioned me to everyone as the child that read her way through fifth grade and got straight As.

    I’m excited to get the book but we’re on a broke streak and it might not be until next weekend. (payday) I’m currently re-reading so I’ll be up to even with what’s going on in sequence.

    I have very mixed feelings about the OOTP movie…

  12. Rory Harper Says:

    We just fininished reading Chapter Three at 2 a.m., after getting the book at a mob scene at Hastings at midnight.

    Harry and Hermione died at the end of this chapter. Big shocker. Guess it’s all up to Ron now.

  13. Morgan J. Locke Says:

    I’m going to have to kill you now.

  14. Caroline Spector Says:

    Rory,

    Ditto what Morgan said. But it’ll be longer and more painful my way.

Leave a Comment

Please note: Comment moderation is enabled and may delay your comment. There is no need to resubmit your comment.

Powered by Wordpress
Template based on GREENLEAF by Design4